In recent years, there has been a notable trend of combining Jaimini’s Rashi-specific principles with Parashara’s Graha-specific Dasa system. However, it’s crucial to recognize that these are distinct predictive methodologies, each with its own set of rules, and should not be intermingled. Employing Graha aspects or natural Karakas within Jaimini’s system, or using Chara Karakas and Rashi aspects in Parashara’s system, can lead to contradictions and confusion.
Authors Hart Defouw and Robert Svoboda emphasize this point in their book, “Light On Life,” stating that mixing indicators from both systems is illogical and akin to using diesel fuel in a petrol engine. Similarly, Prof. P.S. Sastri, in his translation of “Jaimini Sutram,” warns that the integration of Jaimini’s principles into Parashara’s texts may cause students to inadvertently mix the two systems, resulting in confusion.
To effectively study Jyotish, it’s essential to understand the fundamental differences between these systems. For instance, Jaimini utilizes Rashi aspects, where planets in Cardinal signs aspect all Fixed signs except the adjacent one, planets in Fixed signs aspect all Cardinal signs except the previous one, and planets in Common signs aspect all other Common signs. In contrast, Parashara’s system employs Graha aspects, with specific planets casting additional aspects: Mars aspects the 4th and 8th houses from itself, Jupiter the 5th and 9th, and Saturn the 3rd and 10th.
Additionally, Jaimini’s system defines Chara Karakas based on the degrees of planets, assigning roles such as Atmakaraka (significator of self) and Amatyakaraka (significator of mind/status). Parashara’s system, however, assigns natural Karakas to planets, like the Sun representing the self/soul and the Moon representing the mother.
Understanding these distinctions is vital for accurate interpretation and application of astrological principles.
For those interested in delving deeper into these topics, the following books are recommended:
Light On Life
Authored by Hart Defouw ( Hart De Fouw ) and Robert Svoboda, this book provides insights into the nuances of Jyotish, emphasizing the importance of not conflating different astrological systems.
Jaimini or Parashara: A Comparative Analysis of Two Astrological Systems
Introduction
The ancient Indian science of astrology, known as Jyotisha, is a profound system of knowledge with contributions from numerous sages and scholars. Among the most prominent are Maharishi Parashara, the author of the foundational text Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, and Maharishi Jaimini, the author of the Jaimini Sutras. While both systems share common roots in Vedic astrology, they diverge in their approaches, methodologies, and interpretations. This article explores the key differences and connections between the Jaimini and Parashara systems, offering insights into their unique contributions to astrology.
Overview of the Jaimini System
The Jaimini Sutras is a Sanskrit text attributed to Maharishi Jaimini, a disciple of Vyasa and the founder of the Purva Mimamsa school of philosophy. The Jaimini system, as described in the Jaimini Sutras, is distinctly different from the Parashara system in several ways:
- Focus on Rasi (Sign) Aspects: Unlike the Parashara system, which emphasizes planetary aspects, the Jaimini system assigns aspects to Rasis or zodiac signs.
- Determination of Karakas: In the Jaimini system, Karakas (significators) are determined based on the longitudes of planets within specific signs. This method differs significantly from the Parashara system’s fixed Karaka assignments.
- Use of Dashas: The Jaimini system employs unique Dashas (time periods), such as Chara Dasha, which are assigned to Rasis rather than Nakshatras (lunar constellations).
- Complex Badhaka Bhavas: The determination of obstructive houses (Badhaka Bhavas) in the Jaimini system is more intricate, requiring careful analysis.
The Jaimini Sutras covers various topics, including Karakamsa, Arudha, Upapada, longevity, diseases, progeny, and even prenatal epochs.
Overview of the Parashara System
The Parashara system, as outlined in the Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, is widely regarded as the foundation of Vedic astrology. It provides a comprehensive framework for astrological analysis, including planetary aspects, Nakshatra-based Dashas (e.g., Vimshottari Dasha), and a detailed examination of Bhavas (houses). Key features of the Parashara system include:
- Planetary Aspects: The system emphasizes the relationships between planets based on angular distances.
- Fixed Karakas: Each planet is assigned a fixed role as a significator for specific areas of life (e.g., Jupiter for children, Venus for marriage).
- Emphasis on Nakshatras: The Parashara system places significant importance on Nakshatras for timing events and analyzing planetary strengths.
Key Differences Between Jaimini and Parashara Systems
While both systems are rooted in the same Vedic tradition, their approaches are complementary rather than contradictory. Some of the key differences include:
| Aspect | Jaimini System | Parashara System |
|---|---|---|
| Aspects | Rasi (sign-based) aspects | Planetary aspects |
| Karakas | Determined by planetary longitudes | Fixed significators based on planets |
| Dashas | Rasi-based Dashas (e.g., Chara Dasha) | Nakshatra-based Dashas (e.g., Vimshottari Dasha) |
| Badhaka Bhavas | Complex and unique to Rasis | Simpler, based on planetary placements |
| Focus | Signs and their relationships | Planets and their interactions |
Interconnection Between Jaimini and Parashara Systems
Some scholars suggest that the Jaimini system may have evolved as an offshoot of the Parashara system. In his book Light on Life, Hart De Fouw speculates that a commentator might have developed Jaimini Jyotish from Parashara’s framework, extracting shared principles while introducing innovative concepts. Furthermore, Maharishi Jaimini himself acknowledges the truth of principles propounded in other works in Sutra 37 of Adhyaya II Pada IV, stating “सिद्धमन्यत्” (Siddhamanyat), meaning “established elsewhere.”
Challenges in Understanding the Jaimini Sutras
The Jaimini Sutras is known for its brevity and enigmatic style, making it challenging for readers without guidance from commentaries. Commentaries by scholars such as Neelakantha and Premanidhi attempt to decode the sutras, but differences in interpretation persist. Bangalore Venkata Raman, in his work Studies in Jaimini Astrology, notes that the Jaimini system’s complexity and the variety of Dashas mentioned can leave readers puzzled, especially when principles are open to multiple interpretations.
Conclusion
The Jaimini and Parashara systems of astrology are two sides of the same coin, each offering unique tools and perspectives for astrological analysis. While the Parashara system serves as the foundational framework for Vedic astrology, the Jaimini system provides specialized techniques that enhance predictive accuracy. Together, they form a complementary blend of tradition and innovation, enriching the field of Jyotisha.
For more detailed insights into the Jaimini and Parashara systems, visit AstJo.
Leave a Reply